Сombating hybrid threats in the EU (by the European Union regulation and legal framework)

  • Аnastasiia Khmel Petro Mohyla Black Sea National University
Keywords: EU, European Commission, High Representative, hybrid threats, disinformation, Hybrid Fusion Cell


Given the relevance of the topic of combating hybrid threats to Ukraine, the author draws attention to the regulatory framework of the European Union, which identifies hybrid threats and provides actions and measures to combat them. During 2016-2020, the main EU documents were adopted, which consider the definition of hybrid threats, identify areas where they can be implemented and identify measures to combat them: «Joint structure to combat hybrid threats – the response of the European Union» (2016), «Improving resilience and Strengthening Capabilities to Overcome Hybrid Threats» (2018), «Report on the Implementation of the Joint Program on Countering Hybrid Threats 2016 and the Joint Communication 2018 on Enhancing Sustainability and Strengthening Capabilities to Overcome Hybrid Threats ”(2020), EU Security Strategy 2020. Hybrid threats include cybersecurity, critical infrastructure, protection of the financial system from illicit use and efforts to combat violent extremism and radicalization, health care, outer space and maritime space. The primary responsibility for combating hybrid threats lies with Member States, but in cases where threats go beyond their borders and affect the organization, the Commission, the High Representative and the newly established bodies are responsible: HFC, East Stratcom, Horizontal Working Group, Center for Excellence in combating hybrid threats. The analyzed documents demonstrate the importance of coordination of all EU institutions in the fight against hybrid threats. If the 2016 document is mostly about the Commission, the High Representative, HFC, INTCEN, EEAS, then the number of institutions involved in such countermeasures will expand the tasks for the Council of the EU, the European Parliament and various EU defense and intelligence agencies.


Download data is not yet available.


Analitychna dopovidʹ do Shchorichnoho Poslannya Prezydenta Ukrayiny do Verkhovnoyi Rady Ukrayiny «Pro vnutrishnye ta zovnishnye stanovyshche Ukrayiny v 2017 rotsi» [Analytical report to the Annual Address of the President of Ukraine to the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine "On the Internal and External Situation of Ukraine in 2017"]. (2017). Kyiv: NISD. Retriеved from: https://cutt.ly/GUY2T0f [in Ukrainian].

Bajarūnas, E. Keršanskas, V. (2019). Hybrid threats: Analysis of their content, challenges posed and measures to overcome. Lithuanian Annual Strategic Review, 16 (1), 123–170. Retriеved from: https://cutt.ly/IUY2Zn3 [in English].

Bajarūnas, E. (2020, March 22). Addressing Hybrid Threats: Priorities for the EU in 2020 and Beyond. European View. DОІ: https://doi.org/10.1177/1781685820912041 [in English].

Fesenko, V. (2016, Hrudenʹ). Spyratʹsya vynyatkovo na vlasni syly i vzyaty vidpovidalʹnistʹ za rozvytok Ukrayiny na sebe [Rely solely on their own strength and take responsibility for the development of Ukraine]. «Hibrydna» viyna Rosiyi – vyklyk i zahroza dlya Yevropy. Kyiv, 24-25. [in Ukrainian].

Fiott, D. Parkes, R. (2019). Protecting Europe: The EU’s response to hybrid threats. European Union Institute for Security Studies (EUISS). Retriеved from: http://www.jstor.com/stable/resrep21143.4 [in English].

Hibrydna viyna: sutnistʹ, vyklyky ta zahrozy: zbirnyk materialiv kruhloho stolu [Hybrid War: Essence, Challenges and Threats: Proceedings of the Round Table] (2021, 8 Lypnya). Kyiv: NA SBU. Retriеved from: https://academy.ssu.gov.ua/uploads/p_57_28744724.pdf [in Ukrainian].

Hibrydni zahrozy Ukrayiny i suspilʹna bezpeka. Dosvid YES i Skhidnoho Partnerstva. Analitychnyy dokument [Hybrid threats to Ukraine and public safety. Experience of the EU and the Eastern Partnership. Analytical document] (2018). Za zahalʹnoyu redaktsiyeyu V.V. Martynyuka. Kyiv. Retriеved from: https://cutt.ly/gUY2GYR [in Ukrainian].

«Hibrydna» viyna Rosiyi – vyklyk i zahroza dlya Yevropy [Russia's "hybrid" war is a challenge and a threat to Europe]. (2016, Hrudenʹ). Kyiv. Retriеved from: https://cutt.ly/QUY2bTV [in Ukrainian].

Lonardo, L. (2021). EU Law Against Hybrid Threats: A First Assessment. European Papers, 6 (2), 1075-1096. Retriеved from: https://cutt.ly/WUY2V2h [in English].

Mahda, E.V. (2015). Hibrydna viyna: vyzhyty i peremohty [Hybrid war: survive and win]. Kharkiv: «Vivat». [in Ukrainian].

Misyura, A., Palyvoda, V. (2018). Kontseptualʹni pidkhody NATO ta ES do zabezpechennya stiykosti derzhavy i suspilʹstva u sferi natsionalʹnoyi bezpeky [NATO and EU Conceptual Approaches to Ensuring the Sustainability of the State and Society in the Sphere of National Security]. Retriеved from: https://cutt.ly/fUY2Ian [in Ukrainian].

Palyvoda, V. (2020). Pidkhody Slovachchyny do borotʹby z hibrydnymy zahrozamy: analityka vid eksperta NISD [Slovakia's approaches to combating hybrid threats: analyst from NISS expert]. Retriеved from: https://niss.gov.ua/en/node/3492 [in Ukrainian].

Palyvoda, V. (2020). Tsentr protydiyi teroryzmu ta hibrydnym zahrozam pry MVS Chesʹkoyi Respubliky [Center for Countering Terrorism and Hybrid Threats at the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Czech Republic]. Retriеved from: https://cutt.ly/jUY2PEP [in Ukrainian].

How to Cite
KhmelА. (2022). Сombating hybrid threats in the EU (by the European Union regulation and legal framework). Acta De Historia & Politica: Saeculum XXI, (03), 91-101. Retrieved from https://ahpsxxi.org/index.php/journal/article/view/52